Education Center › Rug History › Turkish Rug History
Turkish Rug History
800 years of Anatolian weaving, from the Seljuk carpets at the Alaeddin Mosque to the Hereke workshops that supplied the Ottoman court.

Turkish Rug History
The Anatolian weaving tradition is the oldest continuous knotted rug tradition in the Islamic world. Eight hundred years of unbroken production, from the Seljuk carpets in the Alaeddin Mosque at Konya, through the Holbein and Lotto carpets that taught Renaissance Europe what an oriental rug was, through the Ushak and Hereke production that supplied the Ottoman court and the European drawing rooms of the 19th century, and into the DOBAG village cooperatives that are still weaving with natural dyes today. Most articles about Turkish rugs treat the tradition as if it were a single thing. It is not. It is at least four distinct things: the Seljuk court tradition, the Ottoman classical production, the village and tribal weaving that ran in parallel to both, and the imperial workshop output of the 19th century. Each is a real history. Each produced different rugs. None of them substitute for the others. What follows is the full arc, in order.
The Short Answer
Turkish carpet weaving emerged in Anatolia under the Seljuk Turks in the 13th century, evolved into a court art under the Ottomans from the 15th through 17th centuries, supplied Renaissance Europe with the first wave of oriental rugs to enter Western homes, and continued through Hereke imperial workshop production in the 19th century and the DOBAG natural dye revival in the 20th. Turkish weaving uses the symmetric knot, favors geometric design more than Persian weaving does, and produced some of the most important prayer rugs and Renaissance era carpets in the entire oriental rug canon. The tradition runs continuously from roughly 1200 CE to today, with no real gap.
Now the long version.
The Seljuk Beginnings: The Konya Carpets
You cannot tell Turkish rug history without starting in Konya.
In 1905, the Swedish art historian and dealer Fredrik Robert Martin walked into the Alaeddin Mosque in Konya and found eight knotted pile carpets and fragments in a dark corner of the mosque. The Alaeddin Mosque had been built in stages between the mid-12th and mid-13th century under the Anatolian Seljuk sultanate. The carpets had been laid there, repaired periodically, and largely forgotten for something close to six hundred years.
Martin's discovery is one of the most important moments in oriental rug scholarship. Until 1905, the standard assumption was that surviving knotted carpets older than the 15th century didn't really exist. The Konya finds proved otherwise. Three complete carpets and five fragments, woven with the symmetric knot, dyed with natural plant pigments, drawn in a distinctive geometric vocabulary that bore clear visual relationship to contemporary Seljuk stonework and architecture. The dating has been refined since (current scholarship places them in the late 13th to early 14th century, slightly later than originally assumed), but the importance is unchanged. These are the oldest surviving knotted pile carpets in the continuous Islamic weaving tradition.
Twenty years later, in 1925, the American professor R.M. Riefstahl found three more Seljuk era carpets in the Eşrefoğlu Mosque in Beyşehir, about 100 kilometers east of Konya. Then in the mid-1930s, the Swedish scholar Carl Johan Lamm dug up seven more Seljuk fragments in the Fostat excavations outside Cairo, where Anatolian carpets had been traded through medieval Egypt.
Today, the Konya carpets and their Beyşehir and Fostat cousins are housed in the Museum of Turkish and Islamic Arts in Istanbul, the Mevlana Museum in Konya, and a handful of European museums. They use the symmetric (Turkish) knot, they are woven on wool foundations, and they show a characteristic ton sur ton palette of two shades of the same color used together, a technique that does not appear in later Turkish weaving.
Marco Polo, traveling through Anatolia in 1272, wrote that the "best and handsomest carpets in the world are wrought here." Ibn Battuta, a generation later, mentioned Aksaray as a major rug producing center. Anatolian carpets were being exported to Europe and to Mamluk Egypt by the late 13th century. The export trade was already active when the Konya pieces were woven.
The Seljuk era ended in 1302. The carpet tradition didn't.
How Anatolian Rugs Reached Renaissance Europe
Here is a part of Turkish rug history that most articles skip but that any serious rug person should know cold.
From roughly 1400 onward, Anatolian carpets started showing up in European paintings. Hundreds of them. They appear draped over tables in Italian and Flemish religious paintings, used as backdrops for portraits of nobility, and laid under the feet of saints and madonnas. The painters were recording, with documentary precision, the imported carpets that wealthy Europeans were buying through Venice, Genoa, and the Hanseatic trading network.
Three groups of these carpets, named after the painters who recorded them, are now central to early Turkish rug scholarship:
The Holbein carpets, named for Hans Holbein the Younger, who painted at least a dozen Anatolian carpets in his 16th century portraits. Scholars distinguish between "small pattern Holbein" carpets (small octagons arranged in a regular field, surrounded by Kufic style arabesques) and "large pattern Holbein" carpets (with two or three large medallions containing eight pointed stars). Both types are now understood to come from western Anatolia, probably 15th and 16th century.
The Lotto carpets, named for Lorenzo Lotto, the Venetian painter who recorded a distinctive yellow on red arabesque design in multiple paintings from the 1540s. Real Lotto carpets are now firmly attributed to Ushak production from the early 16th century onward.
The Memling guls, the small octagonal medallions with hooked extensions that appear in Hans Memling's late 15th century paintings, are now identified as a recurring Anatolian motif that persists in tribal weaving across the region to this day.
There are also "Crivelli stars," "Bellini" carpets, and several other painter named categories. The point is the same: by 1500, Anatolian rugs were the standard luxury floor and table covering in serious European households, and we know what they looked like because the painters of the period documented them.
For the broader story of how these Renaissance imports eventually became the foundation of the Western antique rug market, see our piece on antique rug history.
The Ottoman Court Era
The Ottoman period (roughly 1300 to 1922, with the high classical era from about 1450 through 1700) is where Turkish weaving moves from craft tradition to organized court production.
A few major developments shaped this era.
The Cairene Ottoman crossover. When the Ottomans conquered Mamluk Egypt in 1517, they inherited the sophisticated Cairo carpet workshops that had been producing Mamluk carpets for over a century. Within a few decades, those Cairo workshops were producing carpets in an Ottoman court style: medallions, floral fields, the kind of design vocabulary that would dominate Ottoman court weaving. The "Cairene" or "Cairo Ottoman" carpets of the 16th and early 17th century are now extraordinarily rare and highly collected.
The great Ushak production. Western Anatolian Ushak became the most important commercial weaving center of the Ottoman period. The classical Ushak medallion carpets (16th to 17th century) are the most internationally recognizable Ottoman product. Smaller Ushak prayer rugs and "Star Ushaks" with their characteristic eight pointed stars are pillars of any serious antique collection. See our glossary entry on Oushak for the regional profile.
The Ottoman court silk pieces. The very finest court production used silk foundations, silk pile, and metal thread. These were never commercial objects. They were diplomatic gifts, palace furnishings, and prestige items. Several survive in mosque collections and museums, including the famous silk prayer rug in the Mevlana Museum in Konya, a gift from Sultan Selim I to the shrine, with approximately 144 knots per square centimeter (over two million knots in the full carpet).
The development of the Anatolian prayer rug as a serious art form. The mihrab niche design, framed by columns and topped by a hanging lamp, became a central genre of Anatolian weaving. The best 17th and 18th century Anatolian prayer rugs, particularly the Ghiordes, Konya, and Kula types, are among the most prized objects in the entire Islamic art canon.
By the late Ottoman period, Anatolian carpets were being woven across a network of city workshops and village production zones that stretched from the Aegean coast to the Iranian frontier. The tradition was the dominant non-Persian weaving culture of the Islamic world.
Anatolian Village and Tribal Weaving
Cities are only part of the story.
Some of the most emotionally resonant Turkish rugs were woven by villagers and nomads working entirely outside the court and commercial workshop systems. The Yörük (literally "those who walk"), the Anatolian tribal weavers who moved seasonally across the highlands of central and eastern Anatolia, produced rugs and flat woven kilims that are very different in character from the workshop pieces.
Yörük weaving is geometric where court weaving is curvilinear. The palette is bolder. The drawing is improvised within tribal conventions rather than executed from cartoons. A Yörük weaver, like a tribal Persian weaver, was working from memory and inherited pattern, not from a paper template. See our glossary entry on Yörük for the broader profile.
The village production sat between tribal and city. Villages had fixed looms in homes. They wove for local use, for dowry, for sale at regional markets, and increasingly through the 19th century for export. The major village weaving zones, each with its own design identity, included Bergama in the west, Milas on the southwest coast, Konya in central Anatolia, Kayseri, and dozens of smaller centers.
For dealers and designers, the village and tribal distinction matters. A homeowner who wants formality and precision usually responds to fine Hereke or classical Ushak. A homeowner who wants bold color, geometric clarity, and the human hand will usually respond more to Yörük, Bergama, or village Konya production. Knowing which person is in front of you is half of selling Anatolian rugs.
The Major Regional Centers
A short guide to the regions every rug professional should be able to recognize.
Ushak. Western Anatolia. The dominant commercial weaving center of the Ottoman classical period. Famous for medallion carpets, Star Ushaks, Lotto carpets, and the soft palette of large pattern late 19th century revivals that flooded American homes between 1880 and 1930. See Oushak.
Ghiordes. Western Anatolia, near Ushak. The classic Ghiordes prayer rug, with a high arched mihrab framed by columns, is one of the iconic forms in oriental rug history. The symmetric knot itself is often called the "Ghiordes knot" after this town. See Ghiordes.
Bergama. Northwest Anatolia. Older and more village character than Ushak. Bold geometric pieces, often square or close to it, with strong reds and blues and ivory grounds. The Bergama style draws clear lineage from the Holbein carpets of the 15th and 16th centuries.
Konya. Central Anatolia, the old Seljuk capital. Konya production today includes both city and village rugs, with the city pieces showing fine prayer rug designs and the village pieces tending toward bolder tribal influence.
Kula. Western Anatolia near Ushak. Known for refined prayer rugs and small format pieces, often with distinctive Ottoman influenced design.
Kayseri. Central Anatolia, east of Konya. A major commercial production center, especially active in the late 19th and early 20th century, with both wool and silk production. Many Kayseri silk pieces are sometimes confused with Persian production.
Milas. Southwestern Anatolia, near the Aegean coast. Bold geometric village rugs, often with distinctive yellow and madder palettes and characteristic mihrab designs in the prayer rugs.
Hereke. A coastal town near Istanbul that I will cover in detail below, because it deserves its own section.
There are dozens of other named weaving centers (Sivas, Karaman, Demirci, Yagcibedir, Ladik, Mucur, Yahyali), each with its own design identity. The glossary in our Education Center covers most of them.
The Hereke Imperial Workshop
In 1843, during a major program to modernize Ottoman state production, Sultan Abdülmecid I established an imperial textile factory in the village of Hereke, on the northern shore of Izmit Bay near Istanbul. The original mission was practical: produce silk textiles, upholstery, and curtains for the rebuilt Dolmabahçe Palace, which was under construction at the time.
Carpet production at Hereke began in 1891, with master weavers brought in from Sivas, Manisa, and Ladik. The Sultan's ambition was straightforward and characteristically Ottoman in scale: the greatest palaces in the world should be furnished with the greatest carpets in the world, and those carpets should be Turkish.
What Hereke produced over the next several decades is some of the most refined hand knotted weaving in the entire oriental rug canon. Silk foundations. Silk pile. Wool on wool pieces for larger formats. Metal thread for prestige work. Knot densities that climb past 360,000 knots per square meter on the finest silk pieces. Designs drawn by court artists, including the French designer Monsieur Chenavard, calibrated to the Baroque and Rococo interiors of Dolmabahçe.
A few specific pieces illustrate the scale of what Hereke was capable of:
The 1897 Yıldız Chalet carpet. Woven for the reception hall of the Yıldız Chalet Pavilion in Istanbul, in honor of Kaiser Wilhelm II's visit during the reign of Sultan Abdülhamid II. Measures 468 square meters. Weighs three tons. Single piece. The kind of object that exists at the absolute outer edge of what hand knotted weaving can produce.
The Dolmabahçe Palace carpets. Over 140 large format carpets and 115 prayer rugs, totaling more than 48,000 square feet of woven floor, were produced for the palace through the late 19th century. Many are still in situ. Some of the Selamlık and Harem rooms at Dolmabahçe still walk on the Hereke pieces they were designed around.
International placements. Hereke pieces went to the International Court of Justice in The Hague, the White House, the Beylerbeyi Palace, and to a long list of diplomatic recipients across Europe and Asia.
The factory burned down in 1878, was rebuilt in 1882, and continued production through the end of the Ottoman period in 1922. After a long interruption in the early Republican era, Hereke production restarted in the mid 20th century and continues today, though at far reduced scale.
What Hereke represents in Turkish rug history is the high point of court controlled, design driven, materially uncompromising Anatolian weaving. For Persian production, the equivalent reference points are Isfahan and the Seirafian workshops. For Turkish production, Hereke is the standard against which everything fine is measured.
The Materials and the Turkish Knot
A few structural facts every dealer should be able to explain.
The defining technical feature of Turkish weaving is the symmetric knot, often called the Turkish knot or the Ghiordes knot. Each knot wraps around two adjacent warps, with both yarn ends emerging together between them. This produces a slightly squarer, more architectural pile texture than the asymmetric Persian knot, and it lends itself to the bolder geometric designs that Anatolian weaving is known for. The Persian asymmetric knot allows finer curves. The Turkish symmetric knot allows more strength and a cleaner geometric vocabulary. Both are valid. They are tools for different design priorities.
Anatolian wool varies significantly by region. The best comes from the central and eastern Anatolian highlands, where cold winters and varied grazing produce springy, lustrous, long fiber wool. The Yörük tribal weavers traditionally had access to some of the finest available raw material, which is one reason the wool quality on a good 19th century Yörük piece outperforms comparable Persian village wool.
Before the late 19th century, Anatolian weavers used natural vegetable dyes derived from madder root (reds), indigo (blues), weld and saffron and chamomile (yellows), walnut (browns), and oak gall (blacks). The "Turkey red" that became famous in European trade was an Anatolian madder preparation, and it gave Turkish rugs their characteristic deep, slightly orange-leaning reds that age with a particular warmth.
Synthetic aniline dyes started entering Anatolian production in the 1860s and 1870s. The early synthetics aged badly (many of the bright purples and pinks of late 19th century Turkish village production are oxidized aniline). This is the disruption that the DOBAG project would later try to reverse.
Symbolism in Turkish Rugs
Anatolian rugs carry a different visual symbolism than Persian rugs.
The Anatolian tradition leans geometric. The medallions are angular, the borders are bordered by geometric guard stripes, and the field designs are often built from repeating tribal motifs rather than from the curvilinear floral fields of Persian court work. This is partly aesthetic and partly technical: the symmetric knot favors angles.
The prayer rug, with its mihrab niche pointing toward Mecca, is the defining Anatolian form. Within the mihrab, the visual language often includes a hanging lamp (referencing the Mosque oil lamp of the Sura al-Nur in the Qur'an), columns flanking the arch, and stylized representations of paradise gardens at the spandrels. Antique Ghiordes, Kula, Konya, and Milas prayer rugs each developed their own variation on this template.
Animal motifs appear in the very earliest Anatolian carpets (the "animal carpets" of the 14th and 15th century, the ones that first reached European painters) and persist in tribal weaving long after they disappear from court production. The elibelinde ("hands on hips") motif, a stylized female figure, recurs in Anatolian village weaving as a symbol of fertility and maternal protection.
The visual language is older than the Ottoman period, older than Seljuk arrival in Anatolia, and in many cases traces back through Turkic, Byzantine, and even older Anatolian sources. Most modern buyers don't know any of this. Most dealers don't either. Knowing it is one of the ways you sell at a different level.
The 20th Century: Synthetic Dyes, Decline, and the DOBAG Revival
The 20th century was hard on Turkish weaving.
Synthetic dyes had already disrupted the natural dye tradition by 1900. The aniline reds and purples that flooded into village production in the 1880s and 1890s either faded badly or oxidized into unflattering browns and grays, and by the early 20th century a significant portion of Anatolian commercial production was using synthetic dyes throughout.
The Republican period after 1923 was also hard on traditional village weaving. Industrialization, urban migration, and economic pressure pulled village women out of the weaving economy and into city work. Master weavers retired without successors. Workshop production at Hereke and similar centers continued at reduced scale, but the broader village tradition was contracting.
By the 1970s, the consensus inside the trade was that Turkish village weaving was in serious decline. The wool was lower quality. The dyes were synthetic. The designs were being copied from popular bestsellers rather than from regional inheritance.
Then in 1981, a German chemist and high school biology teacher named Harald Böhmer, working in cooperation with Marmara University in Istanbul, launched the DOBAG project.
DOBAG (Doğal Boya Araştırma ve Geliştirme Projesi, the Natural Dye Research and Development Project) had a specific technical goal: rebuild traditional natural dye recipes from chemical analysis of antique Anatolian carpets, then teach those recipes to village women in cooperatives that would weave hand spun, naturally dyed pieces under quality control supervised by the university.
The first cooperative was established in villages around Ayvacık, in Çanakkale province. A second branch opened in the Yuntdağ region south of Bergama. The Yuntdağ cooperative became the first women's cooperative in modern Turkey, with real economic implications for the village women involved.
DOBAG carpets are wool on wool, hand carded, hand spun, naturally dyed, symmetric knot, woven in traditional Anatolian designs drawn from each region's inherited pattern vocabulary. Each piece carries a DOBAG certification tag confirming the wool, dye, and design provenance.
The project produces around 1,500 carpets annually. It is small by global rug production standards. But its cultural effect has been disproportionate. DOBAG revived a tradition that the trade had largely written off. It influenced similar natural dye revivals in Iran, Afghanistan, and Pakistan. And it gave the Anatolian village tradition a viable economic structure heading into the 21st century.
Anyone collecting contemporary Turkish weaving should know what DOBAG is and what its certification means.
Why Turkish Rug History Matters at the Point of Sale
A retailer or designer who knows this material has a real advantage in front of a Turkish rug customer.
When a buyer asks why a particular Anatolian piece is priced where it is, you can do better than "because it's Turkish." You can explain that the knot is the symmetric Anatolian knot, that the wool is from a specific regional source, that the dyes are consistent with pre synthetic Anatolian practice, that the design is in the tradition of village production from a specific region with a specific name and a documented history going back to the Ottoman period. You can explain why a Hereke is built differently from an Ushak, why a Yörük piece feels different from a Ghiordes prayer rug, and why neither of them is really comparable to a Persian piece of similar size.
That conversation closes sales. More than that, it positions you as a real expert in a category where most American sellers are weak. Most U.S. dealers know Persian rugs well. Fewer know Turkish well. There is a market gap there, especially as Caucasian and Anatolian tribal pieces continue appreciating in value.
For dealers thinking practically about how to translate this history into a sales conversation, the companion piece is our article on what makes a hand knotted rug worth $5,000 or more.
Common Mistakes About Turkish Rug History
Five misunderstandings that come up constantly in the U.S. market.
1. "Turkish and Persian rugs are basically the same." No. They use different knots (symmetric vs asymmetric), they favor different design languages (geometric vs curvilinear), they come from different cultural and religious environments, and they are different art forms. They are related, but they are not interchangeable. See our Persian rug history article for the parallel tradition.
2. "Turkish rugs are mostly modern reproductions." Wrong. Anatolia has the oldest continuous knotted rug tradition in the Islamic world. The Konya carpets from the 13th and 14th centuries are the earliest surviving Islamic pile rugs. The Ottoman classical production from the 15th through 17th centuries set standards that Persian weaving later adapted. Anyone treating Turkish weaving as a derivative of Persian weaving has it backwards.
3. "Hereke is the only fine Turkish rug." Hereke is the most famous fine workshop, but it is one of several. Fine Kayseri silk production, the best Kula prayer rugs, and the highest end Ushak and Ghiordes pieces all reach comparable levels of craftsmanship in their own categories. Hereke gets the name recognition. The category is broader.
4. "Turkish village rugs aren't valuable." Wrong, and getting wronger every year. Quality antique Anatolian village and tribal pieces (especially Bergama, Yörük, Konya, and Milas) have been appreciating steadily for the last two decades. They are now one of the more active categories in the U.S. antique rug market, partly because the supply is genuinely shrinking and partly because aesthetic taste has shifted toward bold geometric work.
5. "Synthetic dye Turkish rugs aren't real." Same point as in antique rug history: synthetic dyes started entering Anatolian production in the 1860s and 1870s. Plenty of genuinely antique Turkish rugs contain some synthetic dyes, especially in the pinks and purples. Synthetic content affects value. It does not by itself disqualify a piece as authentic.
Frequently Asked Questions
How old is Turkish rug weaving? The earliest surviving Turkish knotted rugs are the Seljuk carpets discovered in the Alaeddin Mosque in Konya in 1905, dated to the late 13th or early 14th century. The weaving tradition almost certainly extends earlier, since the Konya pieces are already technically sophisticated when they appear. The broader Anatolian weaving culture has roots going back into the pre-Islamic Anatolian textile traditions.
What's the difference between Turkish and Persian rugs? Turkish rugs use the symmetric (Turkish or Ghiordes) knot. Persian rugs use the asymmetric (Persian or Senneh) knot. Turkish weaving leans more geometric, Persian more curvilinear. Turkish weaving developed prayer rugs as a major art form. Both traditions are major and ancient, but they are visually and structurally distinct.
What is the most famous Turkish carpet? The classical Ottoman period medallion Ushak carpets and the great Hereke workshop pieces of the late 19th century are probably the most recognized formal Turkish carpets. The Seljuk Konya carpets at the Museum of Turkish and Islamic Arts in Istanbul are the most historically important. The silk prayer carpet in the Mevlana Museum, a 17th century gift from Sultan Selim I, is one of the finest single pieces.
Are Turkish rugs still made today? Yes. Production includes the Hereke workshop (still operating after 180 years), the DOBAG natural dye village cooperatives in western Anatolia, and broader commercial production across the country. Volume is lower than during the Ottoman period or the 19th century export boom, but the tradition is continuous.
What is a Hereke rug? A hand knotted rug woven at the Hereke Imperial Workshop near Istanbul, founded by Sultan Abdülmecid I in 1843. Original Hereke production was exclusively for the Ottoman court and as diplomatic gifts. Modern Hereke continues, often in silk and wool, with high knot densities. Hereke is one of the most refined workshop weaving traditions in oriental rugs.
What is DOBAG? The Natural Dye Research and Development Project, launched in 1981 by Harald Böhmer in cooperation with Marmara University in Istanbul. DOBAG revived traditional natural dye recipes and supports village women's weaving cooperatives in western Anatolia. DOBAG carpets are wool on wool, hand spun, naturally dyed, symmetric knot, certified by Marmara University.
Where can you buy authentic Turkish rugs in the U.S.? Established antique rug dealers and reputable importers carry Turkish inventory. Most major U.S. metros have at least one dealer who specializes in or strongly represents Turkish weaving. The RugIndustry directory lists vetted U.S. dealers and specialists.
Final Expert Takeaway
The Anatolian weaving tradition is the oldest continuous knotted rug tradition in the Islamic world. Eight hundred years of unbroken production. From the Seljuk carpets at the Alaeddin Mosque, through the Holbein and Lotto carpets that taught Renaissance Europe what an oriental rug was, through the Ushak and Hereke production that supplied the Ottoman court and the European drawing rooms of the 19th century, and into the DOBAG cooperatives that are still weaving with natural dyes today.
The tradition is not a museum piece. It is alive. The looms in Hereke are still warm. The cooperatives in Ayvacık are still spinning wool from local sheep. The village weavers in Bergama still draw on patterns their grandmothers used. The continuity is real.
What is also real is the demand pressure. Top tier antique Turkish pieces (early Ushaks, fine Ottoman court production, well preserved Ghiordes prayer rugs, classical Bergama pieces, original Hereke silks) are increasingly scarce in the U.S. market and have been steadily appreciating for the last twenty years. The supply of new fine production has shrunk. The supply of antique inventory in American collections is being absorbed estate by estate. For dealers and designers who can speak this tradition credibly, the next decade is going to be an interesting one.
Turkish rugs are misidentified more often than any other major category in the U.S. market. American buyers learned about oriental rugs through Persians, and the assumption that any formal floral piece must be Persian, or that any bold geometric piece must be a copy, runs through most consumer-level conversations about Anatolian weaving. The category sits between Persian and Caucasian, structurally and visually, and gets correctly identified by maybe one buyer in ten without expert guidance. For the dealer or designer who can speak the tradition credibly, this is an opportunity. Top tier antique Turkish pieces (early Ushaks, fine Ottoman court production, well-preserved Ghiordes prayer rugs, classical Bergama work, original Hereke silks) are increasingly scarce in the U.S. market and have been steadily appreciating for the last two decades. The supply of new fine production has shrunk. The supply of antique inventory in American collections is being absorbed estate by estate. The market exists because the knowledge exists. When the knowledge thins, the market thins with it.